What do I do if I’m the one who can’t trust anymore? Start by admitting your pain is real and normal, then lean on a trained Christian counselor and safe, mature Christian friends who can walk with you. Let trust return slowly through your spouse’s consistent actions, and choose forgiveness one day at a time, knowing God can carry you through both.
You’re Not Broken. You’re Wounded.
I’ve sat on both sides of this conversation. I was the one who broke trust, and I watched what it did to Kath. I can’t tell you I know exactly how it feels to be the betrayed one. But I can come alongside you and tell you what I saw.
Distrust isn’t a character flaw. It’s your heart trying to protect itself from getting hurt again. When someone you counted on proves unsafe, your mind starts scanning for danger. That’s normal.
“Distrust isn’t a character flaw. It’s your heart trying to protect itself.”
The Bible gives us permission to bring this pain straight to God:
“The Lord is close to the brokenhearted and saves those who are crushed in spirit.” (Psalm 34:18, NIV)
Tell the Truth About Your Pain
Early in our story, I handled hurt with control. I tried to “fix” Kath instead of listening to her. I’d even send her to a pastor so she’d get “straightened out.” That never healed anything.
Don’t make the mistake I did. Say what the betrayal did to you, out loud, without being pushed to hurry.
Here’s a simple way to do it:
-
Write down what happened and how it made you feel, in your own words.
-
Use “I” statements: “I feel deeply hurt, and I’m not sure I can trust you right now.”
-
Choose a set time to talk. Avoid marathon sessions that rehash every detail, because those can deepen the wound.
-
Ask for what you need, such as honesty, check-ins, or space.
“Say what the betrayal did to you, out loud, without being pushed to hurry.”
Get Help. Don’t Walk This Alone.
Some pain runs too deep to heal on willpower. In our book, we share how long it took people we love to get counseling and reach forgiveness. For some it took years.
Reach out to:
-
A licensed Christian marriage counselor who has real experience helping couples through infidelity
-
A mature Christian friend or mentor who has been around the block a few more times than you.
-
A Christian pastor or ministry leader who has real counseling training.
-
A Christian recovery or support group for betrayed spouses.
“Some pain runs too deep to heal on willpower.”
Scripture agrees that we need each other:
“Two are better than one… If either of them falls down, one can help the other up.” (Ecclesiastes 4:9-10, NIV)
Let Trust Be Rebuilt, Not Demanded
Trust and forgiveness are different things. Forgiveness is a decision. Trust is rebuilt by repeated, observable actions.
If your spouse is the one who broke trust, here’s what healthy rebuilding looks like. These are things they should be doing, not things you have to prove:
-
Taking full responsibility without excuses or defensiveness
-
Ending all contact with the affair partner
-
Being transparent about phone, money, and whereabouts for a season
-
Answering your questions honestly, even the ones you ask twice
-
Letting you set the pace for emotional and physical intimacy
I can’t rebuild trust with a slick apology or a promise. It took me owning every bit of what I did, with no excuses and no “but you…”, before Kath could even begin to breathe again. Then I had to leave the doors open. Kath could ask anything, and I had to let her see what I’d once kept hidden. That wasn’t about her policing me. It was about showing her there was nothing left in the dark.
“Trust is rebuilt by repeated, observable actions.”
A word to the spouse who broke the trust: Kath and I learned that conditions and control choke intimacy. I had to put trust in the place of control. Let your actions speak louder than your promises.
If you ever feel unsafe, a seasoned Christian counselor can help you decide whether separation is needed.
Choose Forgiveness, One Day at a Time
Forgiveness isn’t saying what happened was okay. It’s releasing the grip that pain has on your heart. Unforgiveness takes away your freedom.
I ask the question in our book that I’d ask you: do you have any unforgiveness in your heart that is stealing your freedom? You don’t have to do it perfectly or all at once.
Try this:
-
Tell God honestly that you don’t feel ready.
-
Ask Him for the willingness to forgive.
-
Make the decision again each time the hurt resurfaces.
-
Keep going to counseling while you do.
“Forgiveness is releasing the grip that pain has on your heart.”
God is in the business of redemption. He took two broken people, Kath and me, and made something new.
“And we know that in all things God works for the good of those who love him.” (Romans 8:28, NIV)
Your story isn’t over. God took two broken people, Kath and me, and made something new, and He can do the same for you. Come alongside someone safe today and take one small step. And when the question comes back, “What do I do if I’m the one who can’t trust anymore?”, remember the answer: you don’t have to walk it alone.
